Caroline Reutter, Caroline's, Inc.

The name says it all. Caroline Reutter's scrumptious caramel cake is a taste that is keeping the traditions and memories of the South alive. The recipe for this seven-layer delicacy was passed down through Caroline's family, as it was in many Southern families, and is as much a part of her Charleston, S.C., heritage as magnolia blossoms and homemade grits.

While food and entertaining are at the center of Southern hospitality, Caroline never expected to make cooking into a business---her background is in design and decorating. "I certainly didn't see myself doing this," she says. It was the occasion of her youngest son's christening 21 years ago that started the ball rolling, when Caroline served her caramel cake for dessert. Clearly, what evolved from there is not only a thriving gourmet gift business but also a means of connecting people to each other and to some of their most cherished memories.

Faithful customer Paul McGaughy of Beaumont, Texas, enjoyed "good Southern cooking and an incredible caramel cake" as a boy growing up in Mississippi. "I was telling my wife one day that I've just got a sweet tooth, and I'm wishing for some caramel cake like we used to get in Tupelo," he says. His wife went searching on the Internet and found Caroline. "I picked up the phone and called her on a Saturday night," he recalls. "I told her I was 64 years old and hadn't had this cake for decades, and I wondered if hers was close to it." Caroline assured McGaughy that her cake was made from an old Southern recipe. McGaughy ordered a cake and says, "It's just 100 percent what I remembered as my grandmother's cake. It brought back a lot of great memories of dad and mom and grandmother and Tupelo, Miss. We'll probably send $300-$500 worth of it to our friends. We don't want them to miss this before they die!" Of Caroline, he says, "She glows. Caroline is such a delightful person. She just radiates love and compassion and sincerity and a desire to make people happy."

Caroline notes that her cake can be frozen, thawed and re-frozen up to six months and can be enjoyed either cold or at room temperature. The cake is shipped frozen to retain freshness. When the frozen ones come out, there is no difference in taste or consistency.

Customers have called Caroline to say, "I can get 200 slices out of your cake. I go to the freezer every night with our sharpest knife and I take a sliver and that's my bedtime snack." Or, "My breakfast every morning is a hot cup of coffee and a piece of frozen caramel cake." Then there were the two men who called at 11:30 one night to say, "Caroline, I just got your cake today. That's the best thing I have ever tasted. I have eaten the whole thing, and I want another one!" Caroline responded, "You've eaten the whole thing? What do you want me to do, call 911?"

The extraordinary caramel cake takes the better part of a day to make and, according to Caroline, there is only one right way to do it. The caramel is the tricky part. "Sugar is just an animal," Caroline says, "and if you don't treat it right at certain stages, it turns on you. Sugar always wants to return to its natural state and what you're trying to do is keep it in another state. If one molecule or grain turns, they all turn---like a domino effect."

Perhaps the largest order Caroline ever filled was from a company in Florida that wanted 2,000 cakes shipped within three days after Thanksgiving. "We got the order in April," Caroline recalls. "I was sitting at my kitchen table planning my garden, and the phone rang. They asked me if I could do it, and I said, 'yeah,' and when I got off the phone, I said, 'Time to incorporate!' I have not stopped running since. I have customers who call at Christmas and order 10, 40, 57, 64. Because my business is a gourmet/gift food business, my volume increases at Christmas, so I go from four employees to 30 for the last six weeks of the year. At that time of year, I'm in the kitchen all of the time."

Caroline insists that service be courteous and personal. She tells her employees, "If you come to work and you're not in a good mood, when you answer the phone, be sure you have a smile on your face because people will hear that smile and that's part of the reason people call. Yes," she says, "I have an extraordinary caramel cake; there's no doubt about it. But people call Caroline for other reasons. They know how we're going to make them feel. It's not about the product. It's about people."

One of Caroline's personal treasures is a file folder filled with notes from customers which she has collected over the years. There are notes from famous people like Bob and Dolores Hope, Billy Dee Williams and Marshall Field.

Caroline will be moving her business into a storefront at Jemal's Bay 50 on Route 50. She will continue to offer her caramel cake, chocolate cake (seven yellow layers with chocolate icing between and on top) and the five-layer white coconut cake, and she plans to add some new variations. Also in the plan---hopefully in time for Christmas but certainly first on the agenda for January---is a Southern pecan pie. Caroline is in the process of developing and perfecting the recipe. Caroline's Cakes can be accessed on the web at

Martie Callaghan is a freelance writer and native Marylander who enjoys spending time with her five grandchildren.


What event in the Annapolis area are you most looking forward to in 2006?

Powerboat Show
Sailboat Show
Renaissance Festival
Seafood Festival
County Fair

Additional comments ?

Last time we asked, "How many past issues of Inside Annapolis Magazine do you have? " Out of all the responses, we found that most of our readers keep at least 3 issues of Inside Annapolis Magazine around the house, but a couple of our readers have over several years of issues! We're glad to hear that so many of you stay with us!

Thanks to all those that voted!

Results Posted Every Issue!!

Backyard Publications, LLC. ©2004. 433 Fourth St, Annapolis, MD 21403 - Phone 410-263-6300 - Fax 410-267-8668